Playing College Sports: What You Really Need to Know (From DI Dreams to Club Teams)

Are you thinking about playing sports in college? Whether you dream of hearing the roar of the crowd at a Division I stadium, or you just love the game and want to stay involved, there’s a spot for everyone. But let’s get real: playing at the college level—especially DI or DII—is no small commitment. So if you’re serious, you need to start planning early.

DI, DII, DIII: What’s the Difference?

  • Division I (DI): The big leagues. These schools have the biggest budgets, huge fan bases, and tons of televised games. Athletes here often receive full scholarships, but in return, sports feel like a full-time job. Expect early practices, long travel, and minimal free time.

  • Division II (DII): More of a balance. You can still get athletic scholarships, but they’re usually partial. There’s more time for academics, friends, and other college activities.

  • Division III (DIII): Academics come first. No athletic scholarships, but you can still get need-based financial aid. DIII schools often have tight-knit teams, small class sizes, and supportive communities. Great if you love your sport but don’t want it to be your entire identity.

Fun Fact: Some schools “play up” in certain sports—like Hobart’s men’s lacrosse team, which competes at the DI level even though the school is DIII.

Ivy League Athletics: High-Level Play, Academic Focus

Yes, Ivies are DI—but they don’t give out athletic scholarships. Instead, they offer generous need-based aid. That means your spot on the team doesn’t determine your financial package. Plus, the Academic Index (AI) means you’ll have to hit high academic standards, too. Still, if you love your sport and hit the books hard, Ivies can be a great option.

So… How Do I Get Recruited?

Recruiting starts with you. Here’s your game plan:

  1. Make a college list. Where do you want to go? What level do you want to play at?

  2. Talk to your coaches. They know your skill level—and often know which schools are looking for players in your position.

  3. Build your athlete resume. Include stats, achievements, GPA, test scores, and a short highlight video.

  4. Email coaches. Make it personal. Show them you know their program and that you’re serious.

  5. Check your messages! Coaches might reach out by email or text. Don’t miss those chances.

  6. Be persistent. If a coach doesn’t respond, follow up. Or call them! Don’t ghost schools just because they’re not your top pick—things can change.

Showcases & Camps: Are They Worth It?

Showcases can be helpful—but they’re not everything. They’re expensive, and coaches often attend with specific athletes in mind. If you can’t afford them, don’t worry—coaches rely heavily on recommendations from your high school and club coaches. So again, those relationships really matter.

Timing Matters (Especially for Spring Sports)

Playing a spring sport like lacrosse or tennis? You may need to start the recruiting process even earlier, since coaches won’t see your senior season. Recruitment timelines also vary by sport and college, so stay on your toes and keep your coaches in the loop.

What If I’m Not Recruited?

No problem. You can still:

  • Try out (aka “walk on”) to a varsity team.

  • Join a club team (great competition, lower commitment).

  • Play intramurals or pick-up games for fun.

You might even pick up a brand-new sport—college is the perfect place to try fencing, crew, or ultimate frisbee.

Campus Visits: Don’t Skip Them!

If a coach invites you for an official visit, go! You’ll stay in the dorms, practice with the team, and really get a feel for the vibe. Ask yourself: do I see myself here? Do I like the players and coaches?

Even if you’re not being recruited, visit schools you’re interested in. Email the coach beforehand—they might meet with you, especially if you want to walk on or play club sports. Every interaction is a chance to build a connection.

TL;DR: Playing College Sports Is a Big Deal, But Totally Worth It

Yes, it’s a lot of work. Yes, it might mean early mornings, long bus rides, and less free time. But for most college athletes, it’s so worth it. You’ll learn time management, make lifelong friends, and feel the adrenaline rush of competition. Whether you’re DI, DIII, or just love the game—there’s a place for you.

Share This Post

Empowering students to Navigate and Succeed at School and at life.

Let’s get started on your college admissions!

Reach us via phone or email.

For Parents: Next Act Consulting

Navigate your family's next chapter with ease.

As parents of college students approach a new chapter in their lives, it’s natural to feel a mix of emotions. You are certainly proud of your child’s accomplishments, but you may also feel a sense of uncertainty about your own future, finding yourself asking “what’s next?

Whether you’re looking to return to school, enter the workforce, start your own business, or simply find new ways to engage with your community, Christine Chapman can help you achieve your goals.

College Cohort Program

Be Empowered & College Ready.

We empower students to navigate the college search and application process with confidence. By demystifying the admissions landscape and clarifying what colleges seek in candidates, we help students align their academics, extracurriculars, and passions with their goals. At Chapman Education, we believe in starting early—because knowledge is power. Our program fosters self-advocacy, community building, and self-reflection, ensuring students are prepared not just for college, but for their future aspirations.

This is a program that was conceived of by our founder but that could not be built without the students who were instrumental in creating a program that would best support them–a program they would have benefitted from.

If you (or your student) would benefit from having a coach, guide and resource to rely on who helps mitigate some of the stress and pressure high school students face regularly these days as they become college ready, our high school college coaching program may be for you!

Secondary School Placement

Your Partner in Secondary School Success.

Our counselors prepare students and their parents for secondary school success from goal setting and school search to application assistance, including student essay and parent statement support, interview preparation, and ongoing advising and advocacy. They also collaborate with school counselors and provide administrative support to ensure a seamless experience for students and families.

College Counseling

We support and empower you every step of the way.

Our dedicated counselors meticulously evaluate student materials, assist in the college search and application processes (freshman and transfer admissions). They actively offer comprehensive support and coaching through our work which includes expert guidance in:

August 3-5 & August 5-7

Vermont Retreat